SearchSearch
  • Subscribe
  • My Bookmarks
  • Member Exclusives
  • Country Life
  • Holiday & Entertaining
  • Food & Drinks
  • Kids & Pets
  • Design Ideas
  • Real Estate
  • Remodeling & Renovation
  • Gardening
  • Home Maintenance
  • Crafts & DIY Projects
  • Country Living Shop
  • Shopping Guides
  • Country Living Fair
  • Newsletter
  • Follow
  • Promotions
  • Other Editions
Opt-Out IconYour Privacy Choices
Privacy NoticeTerms Of Use
Skip to Content
sign in
Subscribe
Search
Logo
sign in
Subscribe
Search
Logo
  • ShoppingDown
  • HomesDown
  • Gardening and OutdoorsDown
  • Antiques and CollectiblesDown
  • RecipesDown
  • Entertainment NewsDown
  • Crafts and DIY
  • TravelDown
  • Pets
  • About UsDown
  • My BookmarksMy Bookmarks
  • NewsletterNewsletter
  • USUSDown
  • Opt-Out IconYour Privacy Choices
  • Privacy NoticeTerms Of Use
x
youtube
facebook
instagram
pinterest
sign in
Subscribe
  • Shopping
    Editors' PicksCaret Left Icon
    • Home and Garden Products
    • Fashion and Beauty
    • Pet Products
    GiftsCaret Left Icon
    • Gifts for Men
    • Gifts for Women
    • Gifts for Kids and Teens
    More in ShoppingCaret Left Icon
    • Deals and Sales
    • Amazon Best Sellers
    • Celeb Favorites
    View All ShoppingCaret Left Icon
  • Homes
    House ToursCaret Left Icon
    • Tiny Homes
    Decorating IdeasCaret Left Icon
    • Farmhouse Decorating Ideas
    • Design Trends
    • Small Spaces
    • Kitchens
    • Bathrooms
    • Outdoor Decorating
    Home MaintenanceCaret Left Icon
    • Organization Ideas
    More in HomesCaret Left Icon
    • Paint Color Inspiration
    • Remodeling and Renovation
    • Real Estate
    • Home and Garden Products
    View All HomesCaret Left Icon
  • Gardening and Outdoors
    GardeningCaret Left Icon
    • Plants and Flowers
    • Houseplants
    • Spring Gardening
    OutdoorsCaret Left Icon
    • Bird-Watching
    • Weather and Sky
    More in Gardening and OutdoorsCaret Left Icon
    • Lawn Care
    • Outdoor Decorating
    • Home and Garden Products
    View All Gardening and OutdoorsCaret Left Icon
  • Antiques and Collectibles
    Antiques and CollectiblesCaret Left Icon
    • What to Collect
    • Appraisals
    • Thrifting Tips
    View All Antiques and CollectiblesCaret Left Icon
  • Recipes
    DinnerCaret Left Icon
    • Healthy Recipes
    • Quick and Easy Dinner Ideas
    • Soups and Stews
    • Sunday Supper
    DessertsCaret Left Icon
    • Pies
    • Cakes
    • Cookies
    Holidays and PartiesCaret Left Icon
    • Game Day
    • Valentine's Day
    More in RecipesCaret Left Icon
    • Breakfast
    • Drinks
    • Appetizers
    • Salads and Sides
    • Kitchen Tips
    • Food News
    View All RecipesCaret Left Icon
  • Entertainment News
    Entertainment NewsCaret Left Icon
    • Country Music News
    • Jokes and Riddles
    • Quotes, Wishes, and Captions
    TV NewsCaret Left Icon
    • HGTV News
    • Chip and Joanna Gaines News
    • Hallmark News
    • Yellowstone Universe
    View All Entertainment NewsCaret Left Icon
  • Crafts and DIY
  • Travel
    TravelCaret Left Icon
    • Best Small Towns
    View All TravelCaret Left Icon
  • Pets
  • About Us
    About UsCaret Left Icon
    • Newsletter
    • Subscribe
    • Country Living Archives
    • Subscriber Exclusives
    View All About UsCaret Left Icon
  • More
  1. Recipes
  2. Healthy Recipes
  3. The Ultimate Grilled Cheese with Tomato

The Ultimate Grilled Cheese with Tomato

This summery sandwich is pure comfort-food heaven.

By Christopher MichelPublished: May 8, 2023
Star
Be the first to review!
Arrow Circle Down IconJump to recipe
tomato and fontina grilled cheese
Becky Luigart-Stayner
Yields:
4 serving(s)
Prep Time:
20 mins
Total Time:
20 mins

Just because a sandwich is simple doesn't mean it can't be stunning. 

Case in point: this tomato grilled cheese. What makes it so special? Thank you for asking! 

First, ingredients: You'll want to use the ripest, sweetest, most flavorful heirloom tomatoes you can get. This is a summer sandwich. Next, soft brioche-style bread is important. It's the best thing for grilled cheese. And you don't want just any old cheese. Save the Cheddar for burgers and instead use Fontina. It's a mild white cheese that melts incredibly well. 

Next: technique. You might be tempted to use butter when frying the bread. This is wrong. Mayonnaise is what you want. Don't love the flavor of mayonnaise? You won't taste it. It's true! 

The mayonnaise will cover every inch of the bread, creating the perfect crispy, toasted exterior, but without any mayo flavor. The extra butter in the pan adds a little more flavor and keeps the bread from sticking. 

End result: A grilled cheese for the ages, with lots of tomato flavor, and plenty of ooey gooey cheesiness. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Ingredients

  • 8

    slices brioche-style white bread

  • 4 Tbsp.

    mayonnaise

  • 8 oz.

    Fontina cheese, sliced

  • 2

    large tomatoes, cut into 8 slices

  • Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper

  • 2 Tbsp.

    unsalted butter

Directions

    1. Step 1Lay bread on a work surface and spread 1/2 tablespoon mayonnaise on each. Turn 4 slices over and top with fontina and tomato, dividing evenly. Season with salt and pepper. Top with remaining bread slices, mayonnaise sides up. 
    2. Step 2Melt 1 tablespoon butter in a large skillet or cast-iron pan over medium heat. Cook sandwiches, in two batches (adding an additional tablespoon of butter for second batch), turning once, until cheese is melted and bread is golden brown, 4 to 6 minutes. Serve immediately.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Readers Also Read

ground beef recipes for weeknight dinner

Best Easy Ground Beef Recipes for Weeknight Dinner

beef stew served with bread butter and a glass of red wine

35 Slow Cooker Recipes You'll Never Get Tired Of

super bowl recipes

Serve Up One of These Comforting Winter Soups

kid friendly dinner ideas

Kid-Friendly Dinner Ideas That Grown-Ups Can Enjoy

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
chicken marsala in a skillet

Quick Dinner Recipes You Can Make in 30 Minutes

weeknight chicken dinner recipes

Easy Weeknight Chicken Recipes

casserole dish filled with a potato chip topping and a serving spoon

68 Cheap Dinner Ideas to Stretch Your Dollars

Cooked chicken legs garnished with cabbage in a skillet.

8 Budget-Friendly Cabbage Recipes

slow cooker chicken noodle soup

Let Our Chicken Soup Recipes Comfort and Heal You

roasted vegetables and chicken with cherry tomatoes and basil

Delicious, Easy Sheet Pan Dinner Recipes

ripe avocados halved with pits and avocado leaves on a white background

3 Simple Shortcuts to Ripen Avocados Quickly

a bowl of mushroom pot pie with scallion drop biscuits

38 Casseroles that are Perfect for Weeknights

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Logo
x
youtube
facebook
instagram
pinterest
NewsletterAbout UsMedia KitPress RoomContact UsCommunity GuidelinesAdvertise OnlineCustomer ServiceSubscribeTurn Off Web NotificationsOther Hearst SubscriptionsEvents and Promotions
Hearst Lifestyle and Design Group - A Part of Hearst Digital Media

A Part of Hearst Digital Media

We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back.

©2026 Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy NoticeCA Notice at CollectionYour CA Privacy Rights/Shine the LightDAA Industry Opt OutTerms of UseSite Map
Opt-Out IconYour Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads